pixelcove
Home Services Work About Blog Contact
Contact Us

Contact Us

Message received.

We'll be in touch within one business day.

Message not sent. Please try again or email support@pixelcove.co.

ChatGPT Fetched Our Pages Live, Then Quoted Versions From Weeks Ago

I asked ChatGPT to read four pages on pixelcove.co. Our server logs show it fetched every one of them live. It still quoted versions of three pages that we replaced 5 to 24 days earlier.

The test

On September 26, 2026, I ran two prompts in ChatGPT on a Pro account. The stream reports the model as gpt-5-6-thinking with its web tool on. The first prompt asked it to search the web and read our homepage and our services page, then say what we charge for an SEO audit. The second asked it to open our About and Local SEO pages "right now" and quote each H1 and first paragraph exactly.

Every request to pixelcove.co goes to a log drain, so I could match each answer against what our server sent. Then I dated every quote against the git history of the site.

What ChatGPT said

The first answer opened with "I checked both pages directly." It then quoted our services page at $5,000 a month for a Growth Retainer and $7,500 a month for Full-Scope Partner. It also flagged that the homepage and the services page disagree on price.

ChatGPT answer that begins: I checked both pages directly. Here's what PixelCove currently says about itself.
Run 1, September 26, 2026. ChatGPT says it checked both pages directly.

We retired both of those tiers on September 2. Since that day, both pages list Local Growth at $2,000 a month and Full-Scope Partner at $5,000.

ChatGPT answer claiming the services page lists Growth Retainer at $5,000 a month and Full-Scope Partner at $7,500 a month.
ChatGPT quotes $5,000 and $7,500 tiers that we retired on September 2.

The second answer quoted the Local SEO page H1 as "SEO services in Andover, MA for local businesses." That heading was live for five days, from September 2 to September 7. It quoted an About page H1 and opening paragraph that we replaced on September 21.

ChatGPT answer quoting the Local SEO page H1 as: SEO services in Andover, MA for local businesses.
Run 2. The quoted H1 was live only from September 2 to September 7.

What our logs show

ChatGPT's fetcher, ChatGPT-User, requested each page at the moment of each prompt. Every request got a 200 from the current production deploy.

Page Fetched (UTC) Status Quote came from
/ Sep 26, 12:23:45 200 September 2 to 25
/services Sep 26, 12:23:45 200 Before September 2
/local-seo Sep 26, 12:29:52 200 September 2 to 7
/about Sep 26, 12:29:52 200 Before September 21

The page titles in the answers were old too. ChatGPT labeled the services page "Services | PixelCove: SEO, Web Dev & Automation", a title we retired on September 21. It still spelled our name PixelCove, which we changed to Pixelcove on September 25.

Why the answer disagreed with itself

The price conflict ChatGPT flagged doesn't exist on our site. It exists between two cached copies of different ages: a homepage copy from after the September 2 repricing and a services copy from before it. A buyer who reads that answer sees a pricing error that we never published.

If you change a price or an offer, ChatGPT can keep quoting the old one for weeks. It can also stitch old and new copies together into a contradiction and attribute it to you.

What we can and can't see

We can't see the text ChatGPT's web tool returned to the model. In the stream we captured, the tool message carried each page's title and a line count, such as "Total lines: 161", and an empty body. So we know a live fetch happened and we know the answer matched an older copy. We don't know how OpenAI combines the two.

OpenAI's search crawler, OAI-SearchBot, is a separate bot. In the first two days of our logging, it requested our robots.txt 10 times and our homepage once. It requested no other page. Two days is a short window, and we'll report a longer one.

This is one site, two prompts, and four pages. ChatGPT quoted three of the four pages from copies we had replaced, and all four titles were out of date.

How to check your own site

  1. Ask ChatGPT to open one of your pages and quote its H1, its first paragraph, and any prices exactly.
  2. Compare each quote with the live page. Anything that doesn't match came from a copy ChatGPT holds.
  3. Date the stale quote. Use your git history or CMS revisions, or the Wayback Machine if you have neither.
  4. Check your server or CDN logs for ChatGPT-User and OAI-SearchBot at the time of your prompt.
  5. Repeat the test a week after any price or offer change.

See what AI tells your buyers.

Pixelcove runs SEO, GEO, and Shopify work on systems we build ourselves. Most engagements start with our $1,500 SEO audit. If AI answers get your prices or pages wrong, let's talk.